Connect with us

World Cup 2014

World Cup: How do France & Germany’s key players compare statistically?

As we enter the latter stages of the World Cup and into what will turn out to be some of the most historic games of the tournament, we will statistically analyse some of the key players of each team based on the systems employed & opposition using Squawka‘s excellent comparison matrix.

Don’t miss | France vs Germany –> 3 Key Questions –> Combined XI


Comparing the two deeper central defenders

Both France & Germany follow a defensive system where one plays slightly ahead of the other. For Germany, Mats Hummels is required to play the role of the man advancing ahead to prevent attacks with Per Mertesacker behind him for cover, while a deeper Raphael Varane performs the same task with either one of Laurent Koscielny or Mamadou Sakho.

FRAGER Defenders Image

Raphael Varane vs Per Mertesacker | via Squawka’s comparison matrix

The younger Varane has had to make more tackles and has been successful to a further degree than his counterpart, making an average of 2 tackles per game compared to 0.5 from Mertesacker. The Arsenal defender stands at 6 feet 6 inches making him one of the most dominant & towering defender aerially; this is reflected in his 2.25 average success per game in the air with Varane failing to assert himself there. Possibly through his higher level of experience when compared to a 21-year-old Varane, Mertesacker has a slightly superior interception success rate with 1.25 per game.

Germany’s possession game also means that Mertesacker is required to participate more in retaining the ball and recycling it with passes. He has more than double total successful passes as compared to Varane who plays in a French system that favours quickly getting the ball into midfield & attack; countering rather than maintaining possession. The more experienced Mertesacker takes the prize.


Comparing the deep central individuals in a three man midfield system

Yohann Cabaye has taken up the role of the deep lying central creative midfielder in the French system, supported on either side by (usually) Paul Pogba & Blaise Matuidi, who are allowed to venture forward. For Germany, captain Philipp Lahm is the only midfielder retaining his possession with the coach rotating the other two. Cabaye is a natural midfield playmaker while Lahm has only recently adopted the possession with not as much creative requirement, or has he?

FRAGER Midfield Image

Yohann Cabaye vs Philipp Lahm | via Squawka’s comparison matrix

Joachim Löw has rightly been questioned for opting to play Lahm in midfield when their full-back position has obvious issues. And while you’d expect Cabaye to be the more creative head among the two, Lahm seems to have been the better individual thus far.

While their pass completion is more or less similar, owing to the aforementioned possession based game Lahm has managed to attempt and succeed at more number of passes. But a 90% + pass completion rate is the more telling statistic as Cabaye isn’t required to play as many passes as the Bayern Munich captain. Lahm seems to edge it in the key passes field as well, but generally he seems to play much more deeper than Cabaye, allowing him more time & space to play out these passes.

In a more attacking sense, Cabaye does average more shots on goal which is likely a reflection of his more natural midfielder instinct while Lahm isn’t quite that type of a player as yet. Defensively they cannot be  differentiated while Cabaye’s impressive stats that match up to Lahm’s in that capacity are a surprise as you wouldn’t expect the PSG midfielder to be as solid at the back.

It’s surprising how closely matched these two players are. Lahm’s creative stats & Cabaye’s defensives one are particularly pleasantly surprising.


Comparing the primary goal scorers

Thomas Müller and Karim Benzema had similar seasons with their respective clubs, both ended up with two trophies while one probably got the more prestigious one. They both now lead the attacking line for their countries and are competing for the Golden Boot award as well.

FRAGER Attack Image

Thomas Müller vs Karim Benzema | via Squawka’s comparison matrix

While Müller has a goal more than Benzema, the latter could easily have had two hat-tricks in the group stages with bad luck and a poor penalty denying him. Müller already has a hat-trick to his name but he has taken lesser shots than his counterpart, significantly. France are in-fact among the top teams in terms of attempted shots, and it is reflected in the individual stats of the two players leading their respective attacks. Benzema has thus far taken nearly double the amount of shots (24) at a superior rate of accuracy (68%).

The more striking statistic is the shot zones. 14 of Benzema’s shots have been from inside the area while 10 is the number for Müller. But when we go deeper and outside the box, there’s a staggering difference; 10 shots have been attempted from outside the box by Benzema, as he has had to play in a wide role on occasion, thus not getting as penetrative as he’d like, while Müller who people would have you believe plays a proper false 9 role (he doesn’t, not always atleast) has taken just 3 shots in 4 games from outside the penalty box.

Benzema’s overall influence on the side is superior as well, often playing the role of playmaker from his wider position creating 13 chances for his team-mates than Müller’s 10. It should also be mentioned though that the possible reason for this could actually be the performances of both sides with France being considered the slightly more consistent team thus far. Benzema seems to be the superior performer.

Thank you for reading. You can share this article through one of the buttons below. Do let us know your thoughts in the comments box below.



Sami Faizullah

Sami Faizullah

Co-founder and Chief Editor here. Obsessed with tactics. Keen follower of young players. Creator of #TalentRadar. Appeared in A Football Report's list of "Best in Football Writing 2012".
Sami Faizullah

100 to Watch


Talent Radar5 hours ago

Premier League’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18

William Sinsky brings you 10 players that could enjoy breakthrough campaigns in the Premier League this season. It’s back. The...

Tactical Analysis5 hours ago

Tactical Analysis: Real Madrid 2-0 Barcelona | Real’s Pressing Excellence

Om Arvind writes a detailed tactical analysis about the Spanish Super Cup second leg that finished Real Madrid 2-0 Barcelona...

Talent Radar1 day ago

Serie A’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18

Simone Torricini brings you 10 players that could enjoy breakthrough campaigns in the Serie A this season. The Under-20 World...

Tactical Analysis1 day ago

Tactical Analysis: Manchester United 4-0 West Ham | Fluidity and exploitation

Ryan Quinn writes a detailed tactical analysis about the Premier League game that finished Manchester United 4-0 West Ham Following the signings...

Talent Radar6 days ago

Eredivisie’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18

Mosope Ominiyi brings you 10 players that could enjoy breakthrough campaigns in the Eredivisie this season. Justin Kluivert // Ajax...

Talent Radar2 weeks ago

Primeira Liga’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18

Jose Miguel Saraiva brings you 10 players that could enjoy breakthrough campaigns in the Primeira Liga this season.

Scout Report2 weeks ago

Scout Report: Ainsley Maitland-Niles | Arsenal’s Versatile Prospect

Mosope Ominiyi provides a detailed scout report on Ainsley Maitland-Niles, Arsenal’s versatile prospect. Arsene Wenger announced that along with 17-year-old winger...

Specials2 weeks ago

Lazio’s Golden Age: The Sergio Cragnotti Era

Football News 24/7  Sam McKeever has a look back at Lazio’s golden era in the 90’s under the ownership of Sergio...

Opinions2 weeks ago

Analysis: Why Nemanja Matic could be Manchester United’s most important signing

Kaushik Goswami has a look at why Nemanja Matic could be Manchester United’s most important signing. Having already lured Romelu...

Opinions2 weeks ago

Monaco’s Moves: Why the Football World should pay attention

While the football world is focused on the players being sold by Monaco, Alex Lynch has a look at how...

Scout Report2 weeks ago

Scout Report: Joel Pereira | Manchester United’s Agile Goalkeeper

Mateus Carvalho provides a comprehensive scout report on Joel Pereira, Manchester United’s agile goalkeeper. At the end of the last season, José...

Talent Radar3 weeks ago

Talent Radar: CONCACAF Gold Cup 2017 | U-23 Team of the Tournament

Football News 24/7  Jose Miguel Saraiva gives us his U-23 Team of the recently concluded CONCACAF Gold Cup featuring the...

Opinions3 weeks ago

Blindside Movements And Mental Overloads: Breaking Down Maurizio Sarri’s Tactics

Cheuk Hei Ho breaks down Maurizio Sarri’s tactics at Napoli looking at how the Italian giants use passing, blindside movements,...

Opinions3 weeks ago

Bayern Munich: What’s their game plan?

Alankrith Shankar writes a detailed article of how we can expect Bayern Munich to set up in the 2017-18 season....

Scout Report3 weeks ago

Scout Report: Juan Foyth | Estudiantes’ Ball-Playing Defender

Kaustubh Pandey provides a detailed scout report about Juan Foyth, Estudiantes’ ball-playing defender. Argentina has, since time immemorial, been a...

Scout Report3 weeks ago

Scout Report: Dayot Upamecano | RB Leipzig’s Precocious Talent

Mateus Carvalho provides a detailed scout report about Dayot Upamecano, RB Leipzig’s precocious talent. RB Leipzig is a source of...

Scout Report4 weeks ago

Scout Report: Philip Billing | Huddersfield’s young midfielder

Patrick Mills provides a detailed scout report about Philip Billing, Huddersfield’s young midfielder. Against the odds, Huddersfield Town, one of the...

Opinions4 weeks ago

Amin Younes: How the German international has redeemed his career

Alex Lynch charts the progress of Amin Younes from his days at Gladbach to his current success at Ajax Besides...

Scout Report4 weeks ago

Scout Report: Edgar Ié | Belenenses’ quick defender

Jose Miguel Saraiva writes a detailed scout report about Edgar Ié, the Belenenses and Portugal centre back. Portugal has been facing...

Opinions4 weeks ago

The Impact of Refereeing Decisions and Need for Technology

Dayann C has a look at the impact of refereeing decisions and need for technology focusing on Barcelona’s comeback win...

Talent Radar Award History

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Young Player Rankings 16-17

More on Outside of the Boot