Connect with us

Tactical Analysis

World Cup Tactical Analysis : France 0-1 Germany | France get caught out early and Germany’s high line shuts out France

The Germans resisted the challenge of their European counterparts and emerged victorious. Constantin Eckner analyses the victory that sends Germany through to another semi-final.


At the end of  a very highly anticipated clash, Germany reached their fourth consecutive World Cup semi-final as Mats Hummels opened the scoring from a set piece in the 12th minute, scoring what turned out to be the winner. Germany looked dangerous going forward in the early phases, while France tried to exploit the space behind the high defensive line of Löw’s team. The scoreline is a perfect reflection of how close the game was, with both sides having ample opportunities to score goals. Eventually, the game fell in favour of the Germans, who just managed to take their chances on the day.

Line-up & Formation

France (4-1-4-1): Lloris, Debuchy, Varane, Sakho (Koscielny 71’), Evra, Cabaye (Remy 73’), Valbuena (Giroud 85’), Pogba, Matuidi, Griezmann, Benzema

Germany (4-3-3): Neuer, Lahm, Boateng, Hummels, Höwedes, Schweinsteiger, Khedira, Kroos (Kramer 90‘), Özil (Götze 83‘), Müller, Klose (Schürrle 69‘)

Goal: Hummels 12’

France Germany Tactics


Basic setup

Joachim Löw made a couple of changes by doing what many people had expected of him. Starting from the first game, Germany’s defensive line had four men who prefer to play at centre-back. However, Löw changed his mind and put Philipp Lahm back in right back. Therefore, the German coach shuffled the midfield a bit. Bastian Schweinsteiger and Sami Khedira were back together in the starting lineup playing alongside Toni Kroos in a 4-3-3/4-2-3-1 hybrid. Miroslav Klose moved up front. Per Mertesacker being left on the bench for Jerome Boateng made sense because both centre-backs needed the pace to cover Karim Benzema and to defend long balls behind the backline.

Just one change was made from the France line-up involved in the victory over Nigeria, with Antoine Griezmann in for Olivier Giroud. Les Bleus mostly played in a 4-1-4-1 that became offensively a 4-1-2-3.


France get caught early

Off the ball France showed a solid organization of their midfield. They formed a tight block behind Benzema and tried to lead Germany’s passes in the build-up to the flanks. However, there was a lack of compactness behind Paul Pogba and Blaise Matuidi. Mesut Özil was hardly involved as he was trapped in the cover shadow. The Arsenal man is not at his best at the moment. Khedira drifted a few times forward to help breaking France’s midfield line.


France saw less of the ball in the first minutes. Les Bleus tried to capitalize on mistakes after long phases of German ball circulation. They focussed on counter attacks. Leaving the ball to the Germans was a good approach. However, Mats Hummels scored early in the game. Kroos delivered a perfect free kick into the box which Hummels headed past Lloris. France looked stunned and lost for a while.


Germany in defence

After the goal, France began to find a passing rhythm. Yohan Cabaye dropped between the centre-backs and played the first passes. Mathieu Debuchy pushed forward, while Mathieu Valbuena searched for the right space. Benedikt Höwedes was often criticised in the last few weeks, but the Schalke man was absolutely fine as left-back against Valbuena and Debuchy. It says a lot that Valbuena was moved to the left flank in the second half.

The Germans kept a high backline and invited balls in over the top. France attempted to work through the left side. Antoine Griezmann received many passes, but was unlucky in the game.

It was also a battle in midfield with a lack of space for France to drive into. Schweinsteiger and Khedira took the threat of Matuidi and Pogba away. Both German holding midfielders were industrious in taking them in man-marking, while Kroos brought balance to the midfield. Matuidi and Pogba had their best actions when they tried to break through quickly. Benzema also frequently took up wider positions to create space for the midfielders.

In Germany’s first games, Löw played Khedira or Schweinsteiger to the right of Lahm, with Kroos pushing forward from the left. The base of midfield has not offered anything like cover for the back four, which itself was vulnerable to pace from out wide. Löw took an interesting step by switching Lahm to right-back and fielding Boateng alongside Hummels. But, again, a number of times a simple ball over the top got Germany’s backline into trouble.

France creating chances behind the German defence. via

France creating chances behind the German defence | 

Adjustments in the second half

Germany created zero chances from open play in the first half. Miroslav Klose displayed a solid performance. He found some space between Yohan Cabaye and the French centre-backs and played a couple of passes into the channels, while Thomas Müller made some diagonal runs. Klose’s movement was great in the first half, but the 36-year-old was exhausted after 60 minutes.

Germany slowed down the game intelligently in the first minutes of the second half. France tried to speed it up later on. Deschamps brought in Loic Remy for Cabaye. A couple of minutes later the French coach swapped Mathieu Valbuena and Olivier Giroud and he changed the formation into a 4-2-4 with two centre forwards, but the distance from Matuidi and Pogba to the striker was greater and it was difficult to play long balls behind the defence and easier for Germany to defend.

Deschamps was not showing tactical genius, when he introduced extra attackers. More players in the box complicated things. France needed to increase their presence in the penalty box by providing depth instead of overloading central spaces too much. France threatened mainly in the first half when les Bleus knocked the ball in behind the defence. However, they seemed lost when that was not an option anymore.

Benzema's shots in the game via

Benzema’s shots in the game | 

Key Player of the Game

Unquestionably Mats Hummels. He scored not only the deciding goal but also made seven effective clearances and two interceptions. The 25-year-old prevented any meaningful chances from the French frontline, while running the German backline. The Borussia Dortmund man is the hope for Germany’s defence, besides the equally superb Manuel Neuer.

Hummels' solid defensive performance via

Hummels’ solid defensive performance |

Where does this leave them?

Germany progressed to the FIFA World Cup semi-finals and Löw’s team has a date with Brazil in Belo Horizonte next Tuesday. They want to put memories of the Spain semi-final four years ago behind them. Getting a win would help them do not only that, but also get closer to that major trophy the country so desperately craves from this generation of talented footballers. France remains an exceptionally young side that can continue to grow ahead of Euro 2016 on home ground. That will be the tournament they want to peak for, and while they will obviously be disappointed about the result, reflection will reveal that this was probably a good showing, and Deschamps can be proud of his side.

Follow Constantin on Twitter @cc_eckner

Constantin Eckner

Constantin Eckner

Constantin Eckner is editor for the tactics blog Spielverlagerung. He writes mostly on Bundesliga, Premier League, La Liga, Serie A, Major League Soccer, and South American football with contributions to various English and German sites.
Constantin Eckner

100 to Watch


Talent Radar3 hours ago

U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #8: Goncalo Guedes and Kai Havertz feature

Sami Faizullah compiles this week's Young Players Team of the Week from across Europe's top seven leagues.

Talent Radar21 hours ago

K-League U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Season 2017: Talent Radar

As the end of the season beckons across Asia, it is time for us at Outside of the Boot to...

Tactical Analysis21 hours ago

Tactical Analysis: Benfica 0-1 Manchester United | Goalkeeping Mistake Decides Close Encounter

Hiko Seijuro provides a tactical analysis about the Champions League match that ended Benfica 0-1 Manchester United SL Benfica hosted...

Talent Radar1 day ago

U17 World Cup 2017 Tactical Player Report: USA 1-4 England

Josh Sippie has a look at the players that stood out during the U17 World Cup quarterfinal that finished USA...

Talent Radar1 day ago

U17 World Cup 2017 Tactical Player Report: Mali 2-1 Ghana

Dan Davis takes a look at the standout players in the U-17 World Cup quarter final between Mali and Ghana....

Scout Report2 days ago

Scout Report: Ezri Konsa | Charlton’s Rising Star

Stefan Vasilev provides a detailed scout report on Charlton’s highly rated defender, Ezri Konsa Charlton Athletic are usually left out...

Tactical Analysis3 days ago

Tactical Analysis: Manchester City 2-1 Napoli | Solid Possession and Press

Ryan Tank writes a comprehensive tactical analysis about the Champions League match that ended Manchester City 2-1 Napoli Manchester City:...

Talent Radar4 days ago

2017-18 Performance Rankings: Top 10 Young Midfielders – Edition 1

Our Talent Radar Rankings, along-with our Talent Radar Team of the Week documents the progress of youngsters across Europe, with...

Specials5 days ago

A Growing Gap: Analysing the Championship’s new financial realities

Richard Pike looks at the finances of the English Football League, specifically the Championship’s new financial realities. As we approach...

Scout Report6 days ago

Scout Report: Vinícius Junior | The most expensive player born this century

Anderson Moura lays down the rule on the world’s most expensive player of the 21st century thus fair, Vinícius Junior....

Talent Radar7 days ago

2017-18 Young Players’ Team of the Week #7: Manchester City’s trio lead the way

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Young Players Team of the Week with the best young...

Tactical Analysis7 days ago

Tactical Analysis: Borussia Dortmund 2-3 RB Leipzig | Press beats Possession

Ryan Tank writes a detailed tactical analysis about the Bundesliga match that ended Borussia Dortmund 2-3 RB Leipzig Line Ups...

Series7 days ago

Tactical Philosophy: Paul Clement

While this website has made its name focusing on the lesser known youth of this beautiful sport, and combined it...

Interviews1 week ago

Interview: Ex-Premier League players on the Problem with Young Footballers

Outside of the Boot had the opportunity to speak with ex-Premier League players – Manchester City’s Paul Dickov, Leicester City’s...

Scout Report1 week ago

Scout Report: Nicolo Barella | Cagliari’s Complete Midfielder

Kaustubh Pandey provides a detailed scout report on Cagliari’s promising Italian midfielder, Nicolo Barella In a country that is as passionate...

Opinions1 week ago

Statiscal Analysis: Which team has the worst injury record in La Liga?

Luke Glassford provides us with a statiscal look at the injuries suffered by various La Liga teams over the past...

Scout Report1 week ago

Scout Report: Chris Willock | Benfica’s ex-Arsenal youth product

Hrishi Anand takes a look at youngster Chris Willock, whose move away from the Premier League could help blaze a...

Scout Report1 week ago

Scout Report: Marlos Moreno | Manchester City’s Colombian flash

Josh Sippie takes a look at Colombian international Marlos Moreno, whose Spanish education will make or break his chances at...

Opinions2 weeks ago

Analysing Kevin De Bruyne: Pep Guardiola’s Total Midfielder

Charles Onwuakpa analyses Kevin De Bruyne, who has quickly developed into Pep Guardiola’s most important player. When we talk about...

Scout Report2 weeks ago

Scout Report: Josh Sargent | USA’s rising star

Josh Sippie takes a look at USA’s brightest young star on the block, Josh Sargent With the Bundesliga’s new prerogative of...

Talent Radar Award History

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Young Player Rankings 17-18

More on Outside of the Boot