Debates are meant to provide a diversity of opinions, with the perspective of various parties justifying the question posed. Debates on Outside of the Boot serve this exact purpose. Writers will engage in these discussions every week, providing readers with that diversity.
This week’s topic is about the Indian Super League (ISL). The ISL has been successful in gathering the attention of football fans and media all over India and indeed beyond. The signing of big name players such as Del Piero, Pires, Ljungberg etc. has ensured that people are at the very least intrigued by the tournament. However, a faction of fans have voiced their concerns regarding the level of impact the tournament will have on Indian football in the long term and effect on the I-League. So can ISL improve Indian football?
Charles Wood: ISL will no doubt will be a success in their first season and drive the audience from their homes to the stadium. The tournament, with IMG-Reliance’s expertise and financial backing, simply can not fail. Timing of the tournament was always going to be crucial and with the U-17 World Cup coming up in 2017, ISL will sow the seeds of interest for the sport and will also give a new lease of life to the “Lakshya 2022”. It has already placed India on the World Football map and will continue to keep it in talks at the global level.
Chintan Mehta: The topic for discussion is very debatable and has a shade of both the answers and being an optimist I would say yes. ISL will help India to wake up from its football slumber.
The sport is popular in only certain areas of the country and with ISL it might create awareness and increase the popularity of the game. Football Enthusiasts will look forward to see the stars of yesteryear perform and impart their knowledge to the youngsters who have seen them only on television sets. With increasing investment, training facilities and pitches will get better which in turn help the players improve their game. ISL might inspire more kids to take the game seriously. Kids have a realistic chance to play with international stars and improve their game, let alone the fact that the pay cheque will quench and satiate their financial needs. It’s a whole new aspect and it is exciting to see what awaits us.
Overall, an interesting project which might turn a few eyes. India with a population of 1.2 billion can be next big untapped market for the scouts. Two and a half months seems like a short period of time and I hope the period of the league is increased in the future but you can’t have everything. A start indeed and let us hope it reaches the height we all expect it to accomplish. (@Chintanmilan07)
Wasi Manazir: Yes. Absolutely. There are far too many cynics around bashing the new league but in my opinion there is no harm at all in money coming into Indian football. Considering that the lack of resources has always been the biggest Achilles heel for the growth of football in the country, I don’t see how money being pumped in it will hurt Indian football. Majority of the fans who watch the established European leagues might not like or appreciate the franchise based system or its potential impact on the I-League, but these arguments are sidestepping the good it can do to the game. The big money foreign players may be long retired or nearing it but I believe their mere presence, experience, and insight will help develop our youngsters understand and improve their game which will be a big boost in improving our national team. Youngsters will have a chance to get noticed and ISL can fast track their ascent to the Indian team or perhaps even earn them trials with foreign teams. Improved infrastructure is another thing to look forward to. I for one see ISL being more good than bad for Indian football.
100 to Watch
U17 World Cup 2017 Tactical Player Report: USA 1-4 England
Josh Sippie has a look at the players that stood out during the U17 World Cup quarterfinal that finished USA...
U17 World Cup 2017 Tactical Player Report: Mali 2-1 Ghana
Dan Davis takes a look at the standout players in the U-17 World Cup quarter final between Mali and Ghana....
Scout Report: Ezri Konsa | Charlton’s Rising Star
Stefan Vasilev provides a detailed scout report on Charlton’s highly rated defender, Ezri Konsa Charlton Athletic are usually left out...
Tactical Analysis: Manchester City 2-1 Napoli | Solid Possession and Press
Ryan Tank writes a comprehensive tactical analysis about the Champions League match that ended Manchester City 2-1 Napoli Manchester City:...
2017-18 Performance Rankings: Top 10 Young Midfielders – Edition 1
Our Talent Radar Rankings, along-with our Talent Radar Team of the Week documents the progress of youngsters across Europe, with...
A Growing Gap: Analysing the Championship’s new financial realities
Richard Pike looks at the finances of the English Football League, specifically the Championship’s new financial realities. As we approach...
Scout Report: Vinícius Junior | The most expensive player born this century
Anderson Moura lays down the rule on the world’s most expensive player of the 21st century thus fair, Vinícius Junior....
2017-18 Young Players’ Team of the Week #7: Manchester City’s trio lead the way
A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Young Players Team of the Week with the best young...
Tactical Analysis: Borussia Dortmund 2-3 RB Leipzig | Press beats Possession
Ryan Tank writes a detailed tactical analysis about the Bundesliga match that ended Borussia Dortmund 2-3 RB Leipzig Line Ups...
Tactical Philosophy: Paul Clement
While this website has made its name focusing on the lesser known youth of this beautiful sport, and combined it...
Interview: Ex-Premier League players on the Problem with Young Footballers
Outside of the Boot had the opportunity to speak with ex-Premier League players – Manchester City’s Paul Dickov, Leicester City’s...
Scout Report: Nicolo Barella | Cagliari’s Complete Midfielder
Kaustubh Pandey provides a detailed scout report on Cagliari’s promising Italian midfielder, Nicolo Barella In a country that is as passionate...
Statiscal Analysis: Which team has the worst injury record in La Liga?
Luke Glassford provides us with a statiscal look at the injuries suffered by various La Liga teams over the past...
Scout Report: Chris Willock | Benfica’s ex-Arsenal youth product
Hrishi Anand takes a look at youngster Chris Willock, whose move away from the Premier League could help blaze a...
Scout Report: Marlos Moreno | Manchester City’s Colombian flash
Josh Sippie takes a look at Colombian international Marlos Moreno, whose Spanish education will make or break his chances at...
Analysing Kevin De Bruyne: Pep Guardiola’s Total Midfielder
Charles Onwuakpa analyses Kevin De Bruyne, who has quickly developed into Pep Guardiola’s most important player. When we talk about...
Scout Report: Josh Sargent | USA’s rising star
Josh Sippie takes a look at USA’s brightest young star on the block, Josh Sargent With the Bundesliga’s new prerogative of...
Scout Report: Timothy Weah | The talented encore to George
Josh Sippie analyses one of PSG and USA’s young starlets, Timothy Weah The United States trek towards international relevance is...
Traveling Barefoot – The Story of Indian Football
Arinjay Ghosh details the topsy-turvy tale of Indian Football through the years.
7 Players to Watch at the U17 World Cup 2017 in India
Brian Hradek highlights seven players who could make an impact at the U17 World Cup 2017 The U17 World Cup...
Talent Radar Award History
Subscribe via Email
Young Player Rankings 17-18
More on Outside of the Boot
Specials2 months ago
Analysis: Mourinho’s Manchester United defence and the 4-4-2
100 to Watch in 201710 months ago
100 Best Young Players to Watch in 2017 | Part 5 | Midfielders
100 to Watch in 201710 months ago
100 Best Young Players to Watch in 2017 | Part 10 | Forwards
Talent Radar2 months ago
La Liga’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18
Talent Radar2 months ago
Serie A’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18
Talent Radar2 months ago
Bundesliga’s 10 Young Breakthrough Players to Watch in 2017-18
Tactical Analysis2 months ago
Tactical Analysis: Liverpool 4-0 Arsenal | Klopp Exposes Wenger’s Stubbornness
Opinions2 months ago
FC Barcelona and their Transfer Recruitment Circus