Connect with us

Uncategorized

Should the January transfer window be abolished?


With a comparatively dull January transfer window, smaller clubs left empty handed mid season and multiple loopholes waiting to be exploited, we ask the question: should the January transfer window be abolished?

bony

With their yellow ties donned, the rumour mill churning, and the unemployed reporters camped at training grounds of Premier League teams around the country, the August and January Transfer Deadline Days represents two of the most media-hyped days of the domestic football season, but with the latter often providing more disappointment than it does entertainment, is it time to consider abolishing the January transfer window?

Only two clubs in the English Premier League could really consider themselves as transfer window winners when the markets slammed shut on February 2nd. Chelsea and Manchester City added significantly to their squads, suggesting that the window really is the domain of the ultra rich.


Strong support

According to the secretary general of FIFPro (the players’ union) Theo van Seggelen, there is reason enough to scrap the concept of transfer windows all together and return to the system used before their compulsory introduction in 2002. It is suggested that footballers are being failed by the clubs in terms of the stability of their contracts, and due to the precarious nature of the windows, over 4,000 grievance cases that boil down to issues with pay or wrongful termination are lodged annually.

Yet, it isn’t just the players that suffer. The window, once seen as a beacon of hope to teams across the country, whether contenders for a top half finish or strugglers looking to avoid the drop, is now a source of constant media attention but little action, and is proving to be a hindrance to clubs.

The main sports news provider in the UK has even turned deadline day into an event – or at least they try to. In reality, very little happened on February 2nd while loan signings from Mansfield to Wigan are hardly likely to fire the imagination. They desperately try to build a fanfare but few of us are really fooled.


Set to backfire       

Creating disharmony in a squad that has spent the previous six months building a rapport, the mid-season introduction of new blood often has negative effects, and despite their best intentions, can seriously harm a manager’s cause should a new signing not breed positive results in a short space of time.

The Premier League saw a small flurry of action to close the January window in 2015, and while coverage of the event was as manic as ever, the popularity and social media buzz seems to have dissipated somewhat, yet clubs persist on making last ditch attempts to sign players that would, if not for time constraints, barely be given a second look. Moreover, the chain of late deals must end somewhere, resulting in at least one club falling victim of the system, as exemplified in Scotland to start 2015.

At the end of last month, Celtic waited until midnight to sign a pair of Dundee United stars, resulting in the Terrors casting their net far and wide to find replacements, and fast. An hour later, they had secured a talented youngster in Robbie Muirhead, who departed Kilmarnock at 1am, after the deadline passed, ensuring the Rugby Park club lost a player that had already made an impact in the league, and weren’t given an opportunity to find a replacement.


Searching for a fairer process

Should the transfer window be abolished, a situation such of this would have allowed Killie to replenish their squad and continue their push for a top half finish in the Scottish Premiership. Of course, a return to the former system would have its own hurdles, of that there is no doubt, but with window that passes, it becomes clearer that the system is in need of reform.

Back in England, there was a similar issue with the signing of Wilfried Bony who crossed over from mid table Swansea City to a Manchester City team looking for their fourth Premier League title. The switch came relatively early in January so manager Garry Monk was given a little more time to source a replacement but where would he find someone of Bony’s quality at such a difficult point of the season? Players may be happy to join up with a club challenging for honours but few will be so keen to sign for a club with very little left in their campaign.

It was a similar situation for Fiorentina who lost their exciting Colombian winger Juan Cuadrado to Premier League leaders Chelsea. The London club now have a stronger squad as they look to close in on another divisional trophy but the Italian side, who were among the favourites to win the Europa League, have suddenly been robbed of one of their best players and now they have to wait until the summer to replace him.


Time for a change of system

Yes, the window may be boring, and of course most fans could name players that have been subject to a January move and gone on to succeed, yet the knock on effect that has upon the squad, and more importantly the now displaced player who has little option other than acceptance, can cause disharmony and disrupts a team’s season so quickly.

Transfers being made on an ad-hoc basis would avoid such issues, and ensure that a Premier League season can be completed in a fairer manner. Despite the cliché, it is often the case that sometimes, you must take one step back to go two steps forward.


 

100 to Watch

Latest

Talent Radar11 months ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #6: Luka Jovic, Anthony Martial and Reiss Nelson feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Talent Radar11 months ago

Talent Radar: A-League’s 10 Young Players to Watch in 2018-19

Brian Bertie writes about the 10 young players to watch in this season’s A-League. Australia have made rapid strides forward...

Interviews12 months ago

Interview: Abneet Bharti on Indian footballers abroad

SU Sintrense defender, Abneet Bharti, the only Indian footballer to be plying his trade in Europe, talks to Kaustubh Pandey...

Talent Radar12 months ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #5: Matthias De Ligt & James Maddison feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Opinions12 months ago

Borja Fernandez: The underappreciated genius of ISL’s infancy

On the eve of the latest edition of the ISL, Arinjay Ghosh pays a tribute to Borja Fernandez, an ISL...

Opinions12 months ago

Tactical Philosophy: Domenico Tedesco

While this website has made its name focusing on the lesser known youth of this beautiful sport, and combined it...

Tactical Analysis12 months ago

Liverpool 3-2 PSG: Liverpool edge deserved victory against dysfunctional PSG

Siyang Xu writes a detailed tactical analysis about the UEFA Champions League match that ended Liverpool 3-2 PSG. Liverpool faced...

Talent Radar12 months ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #4: Matthias De Ligt & Ousmane Dembele feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Opinions12 months ago

UEFA Champions League: The 5 hipster sides to follow this season

Gear up with your organic ginger ale and mystical moustache oil, as Richard Pike briefs us about 5 off beat...

Talent Radar1 year ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #3: Maxi Gomez & Marco Asensio feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Opinions1 year ago

Maurizio Sarri at Chelsea: Tactical Approach & Key Players

Miles Olusina writes about Maurizio Sarri and the approach he is likely to take at Chelsea. Despite a successful 2016/17...

Talent Radar1 year ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #2: Joe Gomez & Bertrand Traore feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Talent Radar1 year ago

2018-19 U-22 Young Players’ Team of the Week #1: Joe Gomez & Kylian Mbappe feature

A regular feature on our website is the Talent Radar Team of the Week with the best young players compiled...

Opinions1 year ago

Julen Lopetegui at Real Madrid: Tactical Approach & Key Players

Aamer Aslam writes about what we can expect from European Champions Real Madrid after the arrival of Julen Lopetegui On...

Opinions1 year ago

Carlo Ancelotti at Napoli: Tactical Approach & Key Players

Charles Onwuakpa writes about Carlo Ancelotti and the approach he is likely to take on at Napoli. After three intense...

Scout Report1 year ago

Scout Report: Gonçalo Paciência | Eintracht’s exquisite forward

Jose Miguel Saraiva writes a detailed scout report about Eintracht Frankfurt’s striker, Gonçalo Paciência. For those who have been attentively observing...

Talent Radar1 year ago

Talent Radar: Liga MX’s 10 Young Players to Watch in 2018-19

Thomas Harrison writes about the 10 players to watch out for in the Liga MX for this coming season. Mexico...

Talent Radar1 year ago

20 Key Young Players to Watch from 20 La Liga Teams

Tom Canton takes a look at they key young players to watch from each of the 20 La Liga teams....

Scout Report1 year ago

Scout Report: Alphonso Davies | Speedy Canadian winger

Griffin O’Neill writes a detailed scout report about Alphonso Davies, the Vancouver Whitecaps winger. While many still believe that the...

Scout Report1 year ago

Scout Report: Diogo Gonçalves | Benfica’s tricky winger

Jose Miguel Saraiva writes a detailed scout report about Benfica’s tricky winger, Diogo Goncalves Having been deprived of their biggest...

Talent Radar Award History

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this site and receive notifications of new posts by email.

More on Outside of the Boot

Previous Next
Close
Test Caption
Test Description goes like this